Saturday, May 12, 2018

Peer Editing Checklist

Peer Editing Checklist


TURN ALL WORK IN TO WWW.TURNITIN.COM



Peer Editing Checklist
Please staple this sheet to your partner's essay.


Peer Editing Checklist

Use the following checklist to help you evaluate your partner’s writing.  Remember to offer 2 constructive suggestions and point out 2 parts you especially like.

Your Name _____________________________  

Your Partner’s Name _____________________


  1. Can you identify the main idea or thesis in this essay?  Yes/No

  1. If so, write the thesis here___________________________________________________

  1. Does the thesis contain the author’s topic and their opinion or stand on this subject?  Yes/No

  1. Does this essay have an introduction?  Yes/No

  1. Does the introduction give an outline/ blueprint of what the author is going to talk about?  Yes/No

  1. Is the blueprint parallel?  Yes/ NO 

  1. Write the blueprint/ or 3 parallel topic sentences here:___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  1. Is the writing clear and understandable?  Yes/No

  1. Are there parts of the essay that are unclear?  If so, underline them and put a question mark next to the passage.

  1. Does the essay have a clearly organized middle section, with ideas separated into paragraphs?  Yes/No

  1. Does each paragraph begin with a topic sentence?  Yes/No

  1. Does each paragraph end with a transition sentence, smoothly connecting the ideas of the previous paragraph to the next?  Yes/No

  1. Does the essay contain persuasive language and strong vocabulary?  Yes/No

  1. If the essay contains little persuasive language, circle 10 nouns, verbs, or adjectives that you think could be changed for stronger words.

  1. Does the essay contain facts to support the claims made?  Yes/No

  1. Does the essay contain contextual evidence to support the claims made?  Yes/No

  1. Does the essay have a concluding paragraph?  Yes/No

  1. Does the conclusion restate the main points of the essay in a new way and give a sense of completion to the essay?  Yes/No

  1. Read the essay out loud without stopping.  Next, read the essay out loud again.  This time, label the problem areas as follows:  AWK  or AWKWARD;  Punctuation error; Poor Structure; Fragment; and Check grammar.

  1. Are there obvious punctuation errors?  Mark them.

  1. Are there obvious grammar errors?  Ex. Subject Verb agreement, tense.  Mark them

  1. Evaluate this essay.  Do not just say, “It’s good.” State the positive, give pointers, and make the writer aware of BIG issues.
Posted by at